Best Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin 2017

When you’re on the hunt for the right type of products for your sensitive skin, it’s easy to get lost in the bold, creative packaging of many brands that claim to have the right cream for you.

Unfortunately, gentlemen, many of your grocery store finds that fit in your budget and smell good aren’t really friendly to your skin at all, so before you drop the first can of shave cream that you find on sale into your basket, please read our guide.

Our suggestions below will help you to start using the best shaving cream for sensitive skin rather than the cheapest one. A quality cream will give you quality results, so make sure you check our tips and suggestions below to start improving your shaving habits!

Consider the Following

Before you select a shaving cream, consider the following:

  • Skin-Friendly. We mentioned above that many creams that you find readily available off the grocery store shelves really aren’t worth the investment, and that’s because they contain harsh ingredients in high quantities that don’t do any favors for your skin.

Stick with natural, skin-friendly creams that have ingredients like Aloe Vera or natural oils and avoid products that are packed with fragrances, alcohol and detergents.

  • Quantity. Don’t expect an excessive lather from a cream. Gels provide much more foam than a cream will, so just remember that a little goes a long way!

Top 6 Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin Chart

PictureNameQuantityPriceRating (1-5)
PictureNameQuantityPriceRating (1-5)
1. Natural Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin - Best Shave Cream for Men - Razor Safe and USA Made By Maple Holistics4 ounces$$4.8
2. Pacific Shaving Company All Natural Shaving Cream - 3 oz3 ounces$4.7
3. C.O. Bigelow Premium Shave Cream with Eucalyptus Oil 5.2 Oz.5.2 ounces$$$4.6
4. Edwin Jagger 99.9% Natural Premium Shaving Cream, 100ml Tub - Sandalwood, 3.4-Ounce3.4 ounces$$4.4
5. Acca Kappa 1869 Shaving Cream 4.4oz/125ml4.4 ounces$$$$4.4
6. Burt's Bees Natural Skin Care Shave Cream for Men, 6 Ounce6 ounces$4.0

Shave the Right Way

Even shaving on average skin can be a bit harsh at times, so for those of you with sensitive skin must approach it with even more caution.

  • Before Shaving…

It’s important to prepare the skin before you add on the cream and begin shaving. Start by wetting your face and then washing it with a gentle cleanser and then rinse.

While your face it still wet, apply the cream and let it sit for a few minutes before you start shaving. This will soften and prepare your facial hairs.

  • After Shaving…

After you shave, pat your skin dry.

Pat, pat, pat! Do not rub it. You’ve just spend so much time gently preparing and shaving it, that rubbing it with a towel is like taking sandpaper to it.

Avoid harsh aftershave sprays that contain alcohol. You’ll probably do best with a nice moisturizer to help keep your skin supple rather than burning it with harsh chemicals.

3 Best Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin Reviews

1. Maple Holistics Assuage Shaving Cream

Maple Holistics has this wonderful shaving cream that is 100% Made in America.

This scentless cream is all-natural and contains oatmeal, aloe and sandalwood to help nourish and moisturize your skin from the moment it touches your face. There are no harsh chemicals, no foaming agents and no annoying fragrances. It is sulfate-free, paraben-free and also cruelty-free, making it a quality cream that will allow you to shave… worry free!

This is the best shaving cream for sensitive skin for men on our list. Natural and skin-friendly!

2. Pacific Shaving Company ps02

This organic shaving cream from the Pacific Shaving Company is another great option for men with sensitive skin.

For its small 3-ounce size, it will last you up to around 40 shaves, which is pretty impressive when you look at the common grocery store brands that cost the same price and don’t last as long.

This cream contains aloe barbadensis leaf juice, natural oils, certified organic Shea butter fruit, organic white and green teas, vitamins and plant extracts that all work together to gently help you to achieve a close shave without an excessive amount of lather.

3. C.O. Bigelow Premium Shave Cream

Italians know their way around the barbershop supplies, and the Italian-made C.O. Bigelow Shave cream is a good example why.

If you love the feel of a creamy cream that offers a close shave with little lather, this is the right product for you.

The eucalyptus oil adds a subtle, refreshing scent and this cream will leave your skin feeling soft and smooth once you’ve rinsed it off.

Guys, you might want to hide this from the ladies in your home. They might just enjoy the scent so much that they’ll use it for their sensitive skin, too!